Top Composting & Food Waste in Milwaukee, Wisconsin Ranked

For Milwaukee restaurants and food service businesses, managing organic waste is a critical operational and environmental consideration. While the city has made strides in residential food scrap diversion through pilot programs, commercial establishments like yours must navigate a landscape of private haulers to establish consistent, compliant food waste recycling services. Implementing an organics diversion program not only aligns with growing sustainability goals but can also streamline back-of-house operations and potentially reduce overall waste disposal costs. This guide outlines the practical steps, key local providers, and essential regulations for setting up a successful food scrap composting system for your business in Milwaukee.

The primary pathway for restaurants to recycle food waste is through contracting with a private commercial hauler. The City of Milwaukee's Department of Public Works (DPW) supports waste reduction initiatives but does not currently provide city-run commercial food waste collection^{1 2}. Instead, businesses must engage with specialized providers such as Compost Crusader, Brew City Compost, or Curbside Composter³. These companies offer tailored services, including the provision of collection containers and scheduled pickups, to handle organic material from commercial kitchens. Any business, including restaurants of all sizes, is eligible to contract with these haulers, making private service the cornerstone of commercial organics recycling in the area¹.

Understanding Milwaukee's Food Waste Landscape

Milwaukee's approach to organic waste is evolving. The city has piloted programs like FEED MKE, which focus on residential drop-off options, demonstrating a municipal commitment to diverting food scraps from landfills^{1 4}. For the commercial sector, however, the infrastructure is driven by private enterprise. This model offers flexibility and scalability for businesses but requires proactive research and contracting. Key players in the ecosystem include the city's Environmental Collaboration Office (ECO), the DPW, and the network of private haulers who provide the necessary logistical solutions³.

Staying informed about local mandates and goals is also wise. Wisconsin has a long-standing recycling law that sets a foundation for waste diversion efforts statewide⁵. While specific commercial food waste mandates are not currently in place in Milwaukee, aligning your operations with best practices for organic waste management positions your business favorably for potential future regulations and meets the expectations of an increasingly eco-conscious customer base.

Setting Up Commercial Organics Collection

Initiating a food waste recycling program involves a few key steps, centered on selecting the right service provider for your volume and needs.

Selecting a Hauler and Service Plan: Begin by contacting local commercial compost haulers for quotes. Services and costs vary widely based on the volume of organic waste you generate, your desired pickup frequency (e.g., weekly, bi-weekly), and your location^{3 6}. Be prepared to discuss your average weekly output of food scraps and soiled paper. Reputable providers like Compost Crusader will work with you to design a cost-effective plan that ensures your bins are serviced before they become overloaded or create odor issues.

Containers and Logistics: Your chosen hauler will typically supply the specialized collection bins. These can range from 32-gallon carts for smaller kitchens to larger dumpsters for high-volume establishments³. A crucial part of setup is understanding and using the correct liners; most haulers require or provide certified compostable bags. Plastic bags are a major contaminant and are strictly prohibited in the compost stream^{7 4}. Clarify with your provider where bins will be placed for pickup (e.g., alley, loading dock) and ensure your staff is trained on the new workflow.

What Can and Cannot Go in the Compost Bin

Strict contamination control is the most critical factor for a successful program. Contaminated loads can be rejected by composting facilities, leading to service disruptions and wasted effort.

Accepted Materials:

• Food Scraps: All food waste is generally accepted, including fruits, vegetables, meat, bones, dairy products, grains, and coffee grounds with filters.
• Soiled Paper Products: Uncoated paper napkins, paper towels, paper plates, and pizza boxes (free of wax lining).
• Compostable Packaging: Only items that are BPI (Biodegradable Products Institute) certified. Always verify with your hauler first^{4 8}.

Strictly Prohibited Materials:

• Plastic Bags (even if labeled "biodegradable" unless BPI-certified compostable).
• Liquids (oils, soups, beverages).
• Glass, Metal, or Foil.
• Styrofoam or other plastics.
• "Compostable" plastics that are not BPI-certified.

Following these guidelines is more stringent than the city's general recycling rules for rinsed containers⁷. Clear, multilingual signage above your compost bins can help kitchen staff separate waste correctly from the start.

Cost Considerations for Food Waste Recycling

Investing in organics diversion comes with a cost, but it should be evaluated against your current waste disposal expenses and sustainability values. Pricing is not standardized and depends entirely on your agreement with your hauler.

Factors Influencing Price:

• Volume & Bin Size: Larger containers cost more to service than smaller carts.
• Pickup Frequency: Weekly service is more expensive than bi-weekly pickup.
• Hauler & Location: Different providers have different rate structures, and travel distance can affect fees.

While costs vary widely, a small café or restaurant might expect monthly fees starting in the $50 to $150 range, while a large restaurant or institutional kitchen could pay several hundred dollars per month based on their needs^{3 6}. When requesting quotes, ask if there are any cost-saving opportunities for committing to a longer contract or maintaining a consistent volume.

Benefits Beyond Disposal

Implementing a food scrap recycling program offers advantages that extend beyond waste logistics.

• Sustainability Leadership: Demonstrates a tangible commitment to environmental stewardship, which can enhance your brand reputation.
• Potential for Lower Trash Costs: Diverting heavy, wet organic waste can reduce the volume and weight of your regular garbage, potentially lowering those disposal fees.
• Staff Engagement: A clear sustainability program can boost team morale and pride.
• Resource Recovery: The food waste collected from Milwaukee businesses is processed into nutrient-rich compost, closing the loop and supporting local agriculture and landscaping.

Compost Crusader

1780 E Bolivar Ave, St Francis, WI 53235

Compost Crusader is a woman-owned business based in Milwaukee, WI, focused on food waste and composting services for restaurants and other local institutions. They provide curbside pick-up of post-consumer food scraps and haul the material to a Department of Natural Resources (DNR) approved compost site. Compost Crusader aims to expand composting infrastructure in southeastern Wisconsin by creating a new compost site to handle a wider range of food scraps and meet growing diversion demands.

3.8

21 Reviews

See more providers in Milwaukee, WI

Navigating Regulations and Best Practices

Staying compliant involves more than just sorting waste. Ensure you understand any local health or sanitation codes related to outdoor bin storage. Your hauler is a valuable resource for ensuring your setup meets all requirements. Furthermore, for businesses hosting events, Milwaukee's Green Events Guide provides excellent recommendations for incorporating food waste diversion into temporary operations, emphasizing the use of certified compostable service ware and clear signage for attendees⁸.

For ongoing success, designate a sustainability coordinator within your staff. This person can monitor bin contamination, communicate with the hauler, and train new employees. Regularly audit your bins to ensure compliance and celebrate your diversion successes with your team and customers. This proactive management turns a service contract into a core part of your operational excellence.

Frequently asked questions

Sources